I actually use the two in conjunction. It gives me a number of options without having to go through other palettes or drawers. Obviously there will be times when I want something in particular that isn’t in the palette or caddy, but for most days these two work well together.
For those that remember this first video, it does look different. I decided to remove the blushes, which means it holds 26 shadows. If I decide to travel with it, I will usually swap out 6 or 12 shadows to put the blush pans back in. Always a fan of versatility.